Practicing ethnography can help improve the writing process.
It requires collecting data, analyzing it, synthesizing, and reflection or a
conclusion. According to our article, ethnography highlights human
relationships, such as the relationships between a researcher and participates
or a teacher and student. The article points out that in learning ethnography
writing, there isn’t one set formula The article further discusses how there isn’t
one set formula because ethnography is writing requires experimentation,
personal voice, style, structure, and a purpose, which can vary depending on
who is writing, who the audience is, and the relationship between the sender
and receiver (pg 176).
In order to write with a stance there needs to be knowledge
and understanding of that particular culture one is writing about or to. This
includes knowledge of the values, habits, relationship dynamics, norms, and
rituals of that particular culture. As we’ve learned, not everyone is the same,
so sometimes generalizing can occur when making a claim about a particular
culture that may exclude certain members of that group.
One important aspect that stood out to me was an important
part of ethnography writing is acknowledging the fact that it can affect the
lives of those described in that writing piece. One cliché example I can think
of is the reality television show, Jersey
Shore, a popular show that portrayed Italian Americans living in the Jersey
Shore. The show only took a very small population of six Italian Americans, who
were loud, obnoxious; by the opinions of most, tan, liked to party, and
identified themselves as ‘guidos.’ After the show was aired and gained popularity,
there was an uproar response by many Italians in America because they believed
the show displayed a false sense of their culture and the people in it. I come
from an Italian family, and as I can say yes we are loud, we have far set
values of the members on the show Jersey Shore. On a few different occasions
I
ran into some people shortly after the show aired that were from Jersey Shore.
Instead of saying where they were from proudly, they felt they had to explain
that their culture is nothing like
the show and felt they were misrepresented. They almost seemed embarrassed from
my observation. This is a shame because obviously MTV did not care or take into
consideration that producing this show had the potential to affect other members
of the Italian culture in a negative way.
Understanding different dynamics of other cultures can be
done by practicing ethnographic writing as well as improve one’s writing. Research,
spending enough time in that culture interacting, learning their values,
habits, and asking questions are all techniques used in ethnographic writing,
which allows a writer to have a valid stance when writing.
I have never really thought about how people from Jersey Shore who don't take part of the lifestyle presented on TV would feel misrepresented. I never watched Jersey Shore myself but have heard a lot about it, so if I ran into the people from Jersey Shore, I'd probably initially react in a negative way, which is kind of terrible...
ReplyDelete